Skip to main content
Toad's Collectibles

Sell your cards to us

Get a quote in seconds and get paid through PayPal or Venmo, or take store credit and get more. Add your cards, then submit your buylist from your cart. Mail-in only, and we cover your shipping on submissions over $100.

How selling to us works

  1. Find your cards

    Search by name, set, or SKU and add each card to your buylist at our live buy price.

  2. Submit from your cart

    Your buylist is saved in your cart. When you're done adding cards, open your cart to review and submit it, and choose PayPal, Venmo or store credit.

  3. Mail us your cards

    We're mail-in only. Pack your cards securely and ship them to the address we email you. When they arrive we check each card against your list and pay you through PayPal, Venmo or store credit. If a card's condition or count is different, we adjust that card's price.